Decisions

Members of the public have a right to complain if they see or hear content (broadcast or made available on an audiovisual on-demand service) that does not meet standards that are set out in statute (Part 3B of the Broadcasting and Other Media Regulation Acts 2009 and 2022) and/or in a media service code and rule. 

The right to make a complaint is provided at section 48(1) of the Broadcasting and Other Media Regulation Acts 2009 and 2022. 

Coimisiún na Meán’s role in relation to complaints is to consider a complaint and decide whether to: 

  1. refer it to be handled by the relevant broadcaster or audiovisual on-demand media service provider;  
  2. dismiss it (in certain circumstances); or   
  3. consider it for investigation. 

Where we do not refer a complaint to the relevant broadcaster or media service provider or dismiss it, we are required to refer the complaint to be considered for investigation. A decision to refer a complaint to be considered for investigation is not a decision that there has been a breach of statutory and/or regulatory standards in the complaint or that an investigation is warranted.

The criteria for our decision is set out in our complaints process.

We are required to publish notice of our complaint decisions on our website.

Database of complaint decisions

The database was last updated with decisions dated 09.09.2025

CAS-03738

Programme:
RTÉ News: Nine O’Clock and Weather
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ One
Date broadcast or accessed:
11.05.2025
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46L(1)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended. BAI Code of Programme Standards: Obligation 16.4. Code of Fairness, Objectivity & Impartiality in News and Current Affairs: Obligations 14.1, 14.3, 14.4.
Short description:
The broadcast includes a report on Pope Leo XIV’s first public address. The complaint alleges that the broadcast was inaccurate as it misquoted the Pope’s statement, which distorted the Pope Leo’s religious views, misled viewers, and demonstrated an expression of the broadcaster’s own views.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
29.07.2025

CAS-03812

Programme:
Sunday with Miriam
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ Radio 1
Date broadcast or accessed:
18.05.2025
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Sections 46L(1)(a) &46J(1)(d) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended. Code of Programme Standards: Obligation 13.1
Short description:
The broadcast includes a discussion reflecting on the Marriage Equality referendum and the decade since. The complainant alleges a derogatory term was used in the segment which caused offence.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
29.07.2025

CAS-03821

Programme:
Morning Ireland
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ Radio 1
Date broadcast or accessed:
22.05.2025
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46L(1)(b) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended. Code of Fairness, Objectivity & Impartiality in News and Current Affairs: Obligations 12.2.3, 12.2.4.
Short description:
This broadcast included an interview with Tánaiste Simon Harris. The complaint alleges the presenter mispresented facts and misled listeners in a statement made during the interview.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting
Commission Decision Date:
29.07.2025

CAS-03831

Programme:
RTÉ News: Six O’Clock and Weather
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ One
Date broadcast or accessed:
16.04.2025
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46L(1)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The broadcast includes a report concerning the conflict between Donald Trump and Harvard University. The complainant alleges that the report contained an expression of the presenter’s personal/political opinion, rather than an objective statement of facts.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
29.07.2025

CAS-03869

Programme:
Rising Time
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ Radio 1
Date broadcast or accessed:
05.05.2025
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46J(1)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The broadcast included the playing of a song titled ‘Palestine’ performed by Christy Moore. The complaint alleges that the song was antisemitic and caused harm and undue offence.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
29.07.2025

CAS-03881 / CAS-04017

Programme:
RTÉ News: Six O’Clock and Weather
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ One
Date broadcast or accessed:
11.05.2025
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46L(1)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended. Code of Fairness, Objectivity & Impartiality in News and Current Affairs: Obligations 12.2.2, 14.1, 14.3.
Short description:
The broadcast includes a report on Pope Leo XIV’s first public address. The complaint alleges that the broadcast was inaccurate as it misquoted the Pope’s statement which misled viewers, and demonstrated an expression of the broadcaster’s own views.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
29.07.2025

CAS-03885

Programme:
Drivetime
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ Radio 1
Date broadcast or accessed:
23.04.2025
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46L(1)(b) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The broadcast includes an interview with the manager of Irish rap group Kneecap. The complainant alleges that the broadcast was not objective, impartial or fair to all interests concerned.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
29.07.2025

CAS-03926

Programme:
Morning Ireland
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ Radio 1
Date broadcast or accessed:
27.05.2025
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46L(1)(b) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended. Code of Fairness, Objectivity & Impartiality in News and Current Affairs: Obligations 12.2.2, 14.3, 14.5, 14.6.
Short description:
The broadcast includes an interview with Senator Frances Black discussing the proposed Occupied Territories Bill. The complaint alleges the broadcast included an expression of the presenter’s own views.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
29.07.2025

CAS-03993

Programme:
RTÉ News: Nine O’Clock and Weather
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ One
Date broadcast or accessed:
11.05.2025
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46L(1)(a), of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended. Code of Fairness, Objectivity & Impartiality in News and Current Affairs: Obligations 12.2.2, 14.1, 14.3.
Short description:
The broadcast includes a report on Pope Leo XIV’s first public address. The complaint alleges that the broadcast was inaccurate as it misquoted the Pope’s statement which misled viewers and demonstrated an expression of the broadcaster’s own views.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
29.07.2025

CAS-04001

Programme:
The Hard Shoulder
Broadcast / VOD service:
Newstalk 106-108FM
Date broadcast or accessed:
16.05.2025
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46L(1)(b) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended. Code of Fairness, Objectivity & Impartiality in News and Current Affairs: Obligations 12.2.2, 14.3, 14.5, 14.6.
Short description:
The broadcast includes an interview with a trans activist discussing the UK Supreme Court ruling on the legal definition of “woman”. The complaint alleges that the broadcast was biased, misleading and emotionally harmful to female listeners, failing to meet the requirements of fairness, accuracy and impartiality.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
29.07.2025

CAS-04110

Programme:
Adhmhaidin
Broadcast / VOD service:
Raidió na Gaeltachta
Date broadcast or accessed:
09.04.2025
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46L(1)(b) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended. Code of Fairness, Objectivity & Impartiality in News and Current Affairs: Obligations 12.2.2 & 14.6.
Short description:
The complaint is about an interview with a County Councillor about the proposed use of a former nursing home in Uachtar Ard to house international protection applicants. The complaint alleges the broadcast was not impartial and caused harm and offence.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
29.07.2025

CAS-02475

Programme:
Real Life with Lucy
Broadcast / VOD service:
Virgin Media One
Date broadcast or accessed:
14.10.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Sections 46L(1)(b) 46J(1)(a), 46J(1)(b) & 46J(1)(d) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended. BAI Code of Programme Standards: Principles 3, 4 & 5. BAI Code of Fairness, Objectivity & Impartiality: Rules 2, 17, 19, 20 & 22
Short description:
The complaint alleged that the broadcast was biased, not objective or impartial and contained the broadcaster’s own views. The complaint further alleged that the broadcast contained misleading inaccuracies, could incite to hatred and failed to protect the audience.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
24.06.2025

CAS-03135

Programme:
RTÉ News: Nine O’Clock and Weather
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ One
Date broadcast or accessed:
03.01.2025
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Sections 46J(1)(a) & 46J(1)(b) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The complaint alleged that the news report regarding the death of a woman caused undue offence and risked harm and incitement to violence against women.
Outcome:
Referred
Commission Decision:
Refer the complaint to an authorised person to be considered for investigation, pursuant to section 48(5) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended
Commission Decision Date:
24.06.2025

CAS-03402

Programme:
RTÉ News: Six One and Weather
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ One
Date broadcast or accessed:
02.03.2025
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Code of Fairness, Objectivity & Impartiality: Obligation 12.2.3
Short description:
The complaint alleged that about a news report regarding proposed changes to the Triple Lock Rule contained inaccurate information.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(b) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
24.06.2025

CAS-03442

Programme:
Prime Time
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ One
Date broadcast or accessed:
18.02.2025
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Sections 46L(1)(b) & 46J(1)(d) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended. Code of Fairness, Objectivity & Impartiality: Obligation 12.2.3
Short description:
The complaint alleged that the segment of the broadcast which focused on the proposed Occupied Territories Bill was inaccurate, not fair to all interests concerned, and lacked a range of views.
Outcome:
Referred
Commission Decision:
Refer the complaint to the broadcaster to be considered under its Code of Practice for Complaint Handling pursuant to section 48(3) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
24.06.2025

CAS-03474

Programme:
RTÉ News: One O’Clock and Weather
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ One
Date broadcast or accessed:
27.03.2025
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46L(1)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended. Code of Fairness, Objectivity & Impartiality: Obligation 14.3
Short description:
The complaint alleged that the report regarding EU tariffs on imported US Vehicles contained misleading information and was biased.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(b) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
24.06.2025

CAS-03694

Programme:
RTÉ News: Nine O’Clock and Weather
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ One
Date broadcast or accessed:
18.03.2025
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46L(1)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The complaint alleged that the report regarding a ceasefire in Gaza was misleading and unbalanced.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
24.06.2025

CAS-03701

Programme:
Prime Time
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ One
Date broadcast or accessed:
06.03.2025
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46L(1)(b) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended. Code of Fairness, Objectivity & Impartiality: Obligations 12.2.3 & 14.1
Short description:
The complaint alleged the broadcast, which focused on the European Union’s policy on defence and Ireland’s defensive vulnerabilities, contained inaccuracies, was misleading, and lacked a range of views.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(b) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
24.06.2025

CAS-03825

Programme:
The Brendan O'Connor show
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ Radio 1
Date broadcast or accessed:
17.05.2025
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46J(1)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The broadcast included an interview with Tommy Tiernan. The complainant alleges that a comment made by Tiernan about the Pope was insulting religious bigotry which caused offence
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
29.05.2025

CAS-02193

Programme:
Three Ireland advertisement
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ One
Date broadcast or accessed:
20.08.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
BAI General Commercial Communications Code (GCCC) Rules 5.4 and 4.1 BAI Code of Programme Standards: Principle 1
Short description:
The complaint is about an advert for Three 5G broadband. The complainant alleges that the advert was misleading and included surreptitious and subliminal messaging.
Outcome:
Referred
Commission Decision:
Refer the complaint to an authorised person to be considered for investigation, pursuant to section 48(5) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
21.05.2025

CAS-02364

Programme:
Tús Áite
Broadcast / VOD service:
Raidió na Gaeltachta, RTÉ
Date broadcast or accessed:
09.07.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46L(1)(b) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The complaint relates to a report about TD Michael Healy Rae’s speech in the Dáil about social media. The complaint alleged that the political correspondent gave a personal opinion during the report.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
21.05.2025

CAS-02523

Programme:
Invisible Men: Ireland's Incels
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ Radio 1 
Date broadcast or accessed:
19.10.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Sections 46J(1)(a) & 46J(1)(d) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The complaint is about a documentary which examines the world of incel subculture. The complaint alleged that the broadcast caused harm and offence to the Japanese subculture of Hikikomori and risked inciting violence and hatred against the subculture. The complaint further alleged the use of an African proverb in the broadcast raised concerns about cultural sensitivity and victim blaming.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
21.05.2025

CAS-02612

Programme:
Prime Time
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ One
Date broadcast or accessed:
15.08.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Sections 46L(1)(b) & 46J(1)(d) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
This complaint is about an interview with the Russian Ambassador. The complaint alleged the interviewer was rude and insulting towards the Russian Ambassador.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
21.05.2025

CAS-02733

Programme:
The Hard Shoulder
Broadcast / VOD service:
Newstalk 106-108FM
Date broadcast or accessed:
03.10.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Sections 46J(1)(a), 46J(1)(b), 46J(1)(d) & 46L(1)(b) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended. BAI Code of Programme Standards: Principle 3. BAI Code of Fairness, Objectivity & Impartiality: Rule 2
Short description:
The complaint is about an interview with the Minister of Education discussing a ‘whistleblower’ interview video circulating online. The complaint alleges that the broadcast was harmful, contained inaccuracies, was not objective or impartial, and incited hatred against the organisation which facilitated the interview, its members and supporters. The complaint further alleged the content could impair the physical, mental of moral development of children, and that no helplines were provided.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
21.05.2025

CAS-02828

Programme:
Moncrieff
Broadcast / VOD service:
Newstalk 106-108FM
Date broadcast or accessed:
12.12.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
BAI Code of Programme Standards: Obligation 16.4
Short description:
The complaint is about a segment where listener questions were discussed by the presenter and panel. The complainant alleged that the broadcast did not show respect for Catholic Mass and the celebration of Christmas and was offensive to those who hold Catholic beliefs.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
21.05.2025

CAS-02838

Programme:
The Hard Shoulder
Broadcast / VOD service:
Newstalk 106-108FM
Date broadcast or accessed:
03.10.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Sections 46J(1)(a), 46J(1)(b), 46J(1)(d) & 46L(1)(b) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended. BAI Code of Programme Standards: Principle 3. BAI Code of Fairness, Objectivity & Impartiality: Rule 2
Short description:
The complaint is about an interview with the Minister of Education discussing a ‘whistleblower’ interview video circulating online. The complaint alleges that the broadcast was harmful, contained inaccuracies, was not objective or impartial, and incited hatred against the organisation which facilitated the interview, its members and supporters. The complaint further alleged the content could impair the physical, mental of moral development of children, and that no helplines were provided.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
21.05.2025

CAS-02840

Programme:
First Dates
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ Two
Date broadcast or accessed:
09.01.2025
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46J(1)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The complaint is about is an episode of a reality TV series where single people are matched for blind dates in a restaurant setting. The complainant alleged that the content was offensive.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(b) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
21.05.2025

CAS-03164

Programme:
The 9 Til Noon Show with Greg Hughes
Broadcast / VOD service:
Highland Radio
Date broadcast or accessed:
11.11.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46L(1)(b) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The complaint is about a segment of the programme where a caller discussed an incident at his grandson’s school. The complainant alleged the story was not factual and the presenter did not remain objective or impartial.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
21.05.2025

CAS-03322

Programme:
Six One News
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ One
Date broadcast or accessed:
20.02.2025
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46L(1)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended. BAI Code of Fairness, Objectivity & Impartiality: Obligation 14.1
Short description:
The complaint is about a report on the UN spokesperson’s statement in relation to deaths of Israeli hostages. The complainant alleged that the report contained inaccuracies and was not objective.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
21.05.2025

CAS-03335

Programme:
The Marty Morrissey Show
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ Radio 1 
Date broadcast or accessed:
03.02.2025
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Sections 46J(1)(a) & 46J(1)(d) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The complaint is about a segment of the programme which discussed a newspaper article about men in gyms. The complainant alleged the comments were bigoted and sexist, caused harm and undue offence and could be likely to incite hatred against men.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
21.05.2025

CAS-01890

Programme:
Nuacht TG4
Broadcast / VOD service:
TG4
Date broadcast or accessed:
29.05.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46L(1)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended. BAI Code of Fairness, Objectivity & Impartiality in News and Current Affairs: Rule 17
Short description:
The complaint is about a news report on the Department of Integration’s decision to locate applicants for international protection in a hotel and subsequent protests. The complaint alleges the report included inaccurate statements.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
06.05.2025

CAS-02196

Programme:
Nationwide 
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ One
Date broadcast or accessed:
12.08.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46L(1)(b) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The complaint is about a segment on the Dun-Laoghaire-Rathdown County Council “living streets” initiative. The complaint alleges the programme was not fair to all interests concerned.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
06.05.2025

CAS-02423

Programme:
Nationwide 
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ One
Date broadcast or accessed:
23.10.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Sections 46J(1)(a) & 46L(1)(b) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The complaint is about the story of a 17-year-old from Killarney who won a greyhound racing competition. The complaint alleges the programme presented a biased version of greyhound life, and that the content shown was harmful and an offence.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
06.05.2025

CAS-02461

Programme:
Botox At Any Cost
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ Player
Date broadcast or accessed:
05.11.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Sections 46L(1)(b), 46J(1)(a), 46J(1)(b) & 46J(1)(e) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The complaint is about a documentary focusing on the regulation of the aesthetics industry in Ireland and the illegal selling of Botox and prescription medicine. The complaint alleges the programme shared personal opinions, incited viewers to commit crime and undermined the authority of state bodies.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
06.05.2025

CAS-02527

Programme:
The Week in Politics
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ One
Date broadcast or accessed:
17.11.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Sections 46J(1)(a) & 46L(1)(b) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The complaint is about a segment of the programme focused on Fianna Fáil TD Willie O’Dea’s comments about the performance of the Minister for Justice, and whether the panel believed his comments to be sexist. The complaint alleges the presenter’s phrasing when questioning the panel about the comments was offensive to women and was harmful to open and objective discussion during an election period.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
06.05.2025

CAS-02548

Programme:
The Week in Politics
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ One
Date broadcast or accessed:
17.11.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46L(1)(b) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The complaint is about a segment of the programme focused on Fianna Fáil TD, Willie O’Dea’s, comments about the performance of the Minister for Justice, and whether the panel believed his comments to be sexist. The complaint alleges the presenter’s phrasing when questioning the panel about the comments was not objective or impartial and expressed her own views and the broadcaster’s own views.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
06.05.2025

CAS-02575

Programme:
The 9 Til Noon Show with Greg Hughes
Broadcast / VOD service:
Highland Radio
Date broadcast or accessed:
11.11.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46J(1)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The complaint is about an interview discussing the contributor’s new book. The complaint alleges that offensive language was used in the programme and that the presenter did not challenge statements made in relation to the Garda Commissioner.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
06.05.2025

CAS-02616

Programme:
Nine O'Clock News
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ One
Date broadcast or accessed:
05.11.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46L(1)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The complaint is about a montage of the US presidential election. The complaint alleges that the ordering of the clips caused a misrepresentation of Donald Trump’s views on abortion.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(b) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
06.05.2025

CAS-02766

Programme:
Six One News
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ One
Date broadcast or accessed:
08.12.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Sections 46J(1)(a), 46J(1)(b) & 46J(1)(e) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The complaint is about a report on the collapse of the Assad regime in Syria, and the reaction of Syrian families in Ireland. The complaint alleges that the report caused harm, incited to crime and undermined the authority of state by showing adults and children sitting out of car windows, with no restraints or seatbelts, driving dangerously on a public road.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
06.05.2025

CAS-02780

Programme:
Adhmhaidin
Broadcast / VOD service:
Raidió na Gaeltachta, RTÉ
Date broadcast or accessed:
21.11.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46L(1)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The complaint is about a news report on weather warnings. The complaint alleges that presenter expresses her own opinion in the report by advising listeners to stay under their duvets for the rest of the morning.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
06.05.2025

CAS-02263

Programme:
The Anton Savage Show
Broadcast / VOD service:
Newstalk 106-108FM
Date broadcast or accessed:
18.08.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46L(1)(b) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended. BAI Code of Fairness, Objectivity & Impartiality in News and Current Affairs: Rules 17 & 19
Short description:
The complaint is about a discussion surrounding Donald Trump’s political rally in Pennsylvania. The complaint alleges the broadcast was biased and not impartial.
Outcome:
Referred
Commission Decision:
Refer the complaint to an authorised person to be considered for investigation, pursuant to section 48(5) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
15.04.2025

CAS-02273

Programme:
Liveline
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ Radio 1
Date broadcast or accessed:
27.09.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46J(1)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended. BAI Code of Programme Standards: Principle 1
Short description:
The complaint is about a discussion with two callers on the theme of strange thefts. The complainant alleges that the presenter made grossly offensive comments in response to one of the stories.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
15.04.2025

CAS-02317

Programme:
Liveline
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ Radio 1
Date broadcast or accessed:
23.08.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Sections 46J(1)(a) & 46L(1)(b) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The complaint is about a discussion about the ban on XL Bully Breed dogs. The complainant alleges that the presenter expressed his own views and shared misinformation.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(d) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
15.04.2025

CAS-02325

Programme:
The Missing Children
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ Player
Date broadcast or accessed:
04.10.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Sections 46J(1)(a), 46J(1)(d) & 46L(1)(b) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The complaint is about a documentary that focused on the Mother and Baby Home in Tuam. The complaint alleges that the programme contained inaccuracies, caused harm and offence, and incited hatred.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
15.04.2025

CAS-02344

Programme:
Stolen
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ Player
Date broadcast or accessed:
26.08.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Sections 46L(1)(b) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended. BAI Code of Programme Standards: Principles 5 & 6
Short description:
The complaint is about a documentary film focused on Mother and Baby Homes around Ireland. The complaint alleges the programme was bias and contained inaccuracies.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended
Commission Decision Date:
15.04.2025

CAS-02427

Programme:
The 8th
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ Player
Date broadcast or accessed:
04.10.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Sections 46J(1)(a), 46J(1)(d) & 46L(1)(b) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The complaint is about a documentary film focused on the campaign to repeal the 8th Amendment. The complaint alleges the programmes contained inaccuracies.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
15.04.2025

CAS-02428

Programme:
Stolen
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ Player
Date broadcast or accessed:
04.10.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Sections 46J(1)(a), 46J(1)(d) & 46L(1)(b) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The complaint is about a documentary film focused on Mother and Baby homes around Ireland. The complaints allege the programme was bias, contained inaccuracies and incited hatred.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
15.04.2025

CAS-01733

Programme:
Drivetime
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ Radio 1
Date broadcast or accessed:
30.04.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Sections 46L(1)(b), 46J(1)(a) & 46J(1)(d) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The complaint is about an interview conducted with an Israeli Government spokesperson, discussing Israel’s intent to invade Rafah. The complaint alleges that the broadcast was biased towards Israel, caused harm and offence, and that false statements were made.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
01.04.2025

CAS-01806

Programme:
Liveline
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ Radio 1
Date broadcast or accessed:
22.05.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Sections 46L(1)(b) & 46J(1)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended. BAI Code of Fairness, Objectivity & Impartiality in News and Current Affairs: Rule 1
Short description:
The complaint is about a discussion on the Irish Government’s decision to recognise the State of Palestine. The complaint alleges that the presenter made biased, harmful and offensive statements, and did not challenge certain contributor statements.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
01.04.2025

CAS-01888

Programme:
Liveline
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ Radio 1
Date broadcast or accessed:
23.05.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Sections 46L(1)(b) & 46J(1)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended. BAI Code of Fairness, Objectivity & Impartiality in News and Current Affairs: Rule 1
Short description:
The complaint is about a discussion on a social media post made by the Israeli Minister for Foreign Affairs in response to the Irish Government’s decision to recognise the State of Palestine. The complaint alleges that false claims were made and that statements made caused harm and offence.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
01.04.2025

CAS-01889

Programme:
Saturday with Colm O’Mongáin
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ Radio 1
Date broadcast or accessed:
25.05.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Sections 46L(1)(b) & 46J(1)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended. BAI Code of Fairness, Objectivity & Impartiality in News and Current Affairs: Rule 1
Short description:
The complaint is about a segment including various politicians who discussed the Irish Government’s decision to recognise the State of Palestinian. The complaint alleges that the broadcast caused harm and offence, and that the guests were treated unfairly.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
01.04.2025

CAS-01966

Programme:
Six One News
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ One
Date broadcast or accessed:
02.07.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Sections 46J(1)(d) & 46J(1)(e) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended. BAI Code of Fairness, Objectivity & Impartiality in News and Current Affairs: Rules 17 & 20
Short description:
he complaint is about an interview discussing racism in Ireland. The Complaint alleges that unchallenged false statements were made which undermined the authority of state and incited hatred against white Irish people.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended. 1st April 2025
Commission Decision Date:
01.04.2025

CAS-02111

Programme:
Nine O’Clock News
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ One
Date broadcast or accessed:
17.06.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Sections 46L(1)(a) & 46J(1)(d) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The complaint is about a news report covering Government tenders for charter flights to deport people whose international protection applications had been denied. The complaint alleges the report was not objective or impartial and that language used in the report could incite hatred and/or violence against asylum seekers.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
01.04.2025

CAS-02140

Programme:
Kildare Today
Broadcast / VOD service:
KFM
Date broadcast or accessed:
21.08.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46L(1)(b) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended. BAI Code of Fairness, Objectivity & Impartiality in News and Current Affairs: Rules 21, 25 & 26
Short description:
The complaint is about a segment regarding OPW staff access to Castletown House in County Kildare. The complaint alleges the broadcaster was biased and that a conflict of interest of one of the contributors was not adequately addressed to listeners.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
01.04.2025

CAS-02158

Programme:
Three Ireland advertisement
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ One
Date broadcast or accessed:
17.08.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
AI General Commercial Communications Code: Rules 5.4 & 4.1& Principle 5
Short description:
The complaint is about an advert for mobile broadband. The complainant alleges that the advert was misleading and included surreptitious and subliminal messaging.
Outcome:
Referred
Commission Decision:
Refer the complaint to an authorised person to be considered for investigation, pursuant to section 48(5) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
01.04.2025

CAS-01171

Programme:
Liveline
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ Radio 1
Date broadcast or accessed:
21.02.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
BAI Code of Fairness, Objectivity & Impartiality in News and Current Affairs: Rules 3 & 8
Short description:
This edition focused on reformed procedures for the accessing of post mastectomy supports put in place by the HSE. The complaint is about the alleged delay in the presenter reading the Department of Health’s statement on air.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
18.03.2025

CAS-01267

Programme:
Ros Na Run
Broadcast / VOD service:
TG4
Date broadcast or accessed:
31.03.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46J(1)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended. BAI Code of Programme Standards: Principle 1
Short description:
The complaint alleges that violence and threats of violence were depicted in the drama programme, which the complainant believes should not be broadcast prior to the 9pm watershed.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
18.03.2025

CAS-01378

Programme:
Ros Na Run
Broadcast / VOD service:
TG4
Date broadcast or accessed:
02.02.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46J(1)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended. BAI Code of Programme Standards: Principle 1
Short description:
The complaint alleges that violence and threats of violence were depicted in the drama programme, which the complainant believes should not be broadcast prior to the 9pm watershed.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
18.03.2025

CAS-01670

Programme:
Brendan O’Connor Radio Show
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ Radio 1
Date broadcast or accessed:
14.04.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Sections 46L(1)(a), 46L(1)(b) & 46L(3) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
This edition was a panel discussion focusing on Simon Harris’ first week as Taoiseach and leader of the Fine Gael party. The complaint alleges that the coverage was biased, unbalanced and lacked impartiality.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
18.03.2025

CAS-01683

Programme:
Liveline
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ Radio 1
Date broadcast or accessed:
21.03.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Sections 46J(1)(a) &46J(1)(d) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended. BAI Code of Programme Standards: Principle 5
Short description:
The complaint is about a discussion on farming practices The complaint alleges comments made by the presenter in relation to Spanish trawlers were xenophobic.
Outcome:
Referred
Commission Decision:
Refer the complaint to an authorised person to be considered for investigation, pursuant to section 48(5) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
18.03.2025

CAS-01720

Programme:
Drivetime
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ Radio 1
Date broadcast or accessed:
25.04.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Sections 46L(1)(a), 46L(1)(b) & 46L(3) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The complaint is about a discussion on the news following the verdict at the inquest of a patient’s death. The complaint alleges that the broadcast was biased and was not impartial.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
18.03.2025

CAS-01776

Programme:
Kramer vs Kramer
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ One
Date broadcast or accessed:
09.06.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
BAI Code of Programme Standards: Principle 1
Short description:
The complaint alleges that the inclusion of a nude woman in the film was offensive, and not appropriate for daytime broadcast.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
18.03.2025

CAS-01786

Programme:
3pm News Bulletin
Broadcast / VOD service:
Galway Bay FM
Date broadcast or accessed:
09.06.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46L(1)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended. BAI Code of Programme Standards: Principle 5
Short description:
The complaint alleges that the analyst’s description of a candidate when reporting on the vote count in the County Galway local elections was partial, sexist and racist.
Outcome:
Referred
Commission Decision:
Refer the complaint to an authorised person to be considered for investigation, pursuant to section 48(5) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
18.03.2025

CAS-01805

Programme:
CountryWide
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ Radio 1
Date broadcast or accessed:
01.06.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Sections 46J(1)(a), 46J(1)(b) & 46J(1)(e) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The complaint alleges that a presenter’s comparison of an oat cookie to illegal drugs was offensive, harmful, and a threat to the state.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
18.03.2025

CAS-01815

Programme:
England VS Denmark Match
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ 2
Date broadcast or accessed:
20.06.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Sections 46J(1)(a) &46L(1)(b) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended. BAI Code of Programme Standards: Principle 3 & 5
Short description:
The complaint alleges that one of the pundit's comments in the pre-match discussion constituted as ‘anti-English bigotry’ which caused harm and offence.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
18.03.2025

CAS-01859

Programme:
Secrets from the Middle Aisle
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ One
Date broadcast or accessed:
03.06.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46J(1)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The complaint alleges that the use of bad language in the documentary caused offence and was not suitable for daytime broadcast.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
18.03.2025

CAS-01878

Programme:
News Bulletin
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ Radio 1
Date broadcast or accessed:
17.06.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46L(1)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The complaint alleges that the report covering the passing of the Nature Restoration Law by the EU was biased, anti-democratic, and did not provide airtime to community, environmental, rural, social and other groups.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
18.03.2025

CAS-01947

Programme:
Today with Claire Byrne
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ Radio 1
Date broadcast or accessed:
28.05.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46L(1)(b) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The complaint alleges that the segment which focused on the pros and cons of plant-based milks was not presented in an objective and impartial manner.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
18.03.2025

CAS-01142- F4K7S9

Programme:
Late Debate Broadcast
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ One
Date broadcast or accessed:
29.01.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Sections 46L(1)(b) & 46J(1)(d) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The complaint alleges that xenophobic comments were made by a contributor in a political debate and that the presenter did not challenge these comments.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
25.02.2025

CAS-01193

Programme:
Drive Time
Broadcast / VOD service:
Life FM
Date broadcast or accessed:
14.03.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Sections 46J(1)(a), 46J(1)(e), 46L(1)(b) & 46L(4) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The complaint is about the airing of a podcast from The Times of Israel, which discusses an Israel Defence Force (IDF) Commander’s comments at an IDF briefing. The complainant believes the broadcast promoted a one-sided view of the conflict in Gaza and that the broadcast did not meet requirements for fairness, objectivity and impartiality.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Refer the complaint to an authorised person to be considered for investigation, pursuant to section 48(5) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
25.02.2025

CAS-01221

Programme:
Six One News
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ
Date broadcast or accessed:
12.02.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46J(1)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The complaint is about an interview with the former Israeli ambassador to Ireland, Dana Erlich. The complaint alleges that inaccuracies were not challenged in the broadcast.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
25.02.2025

CAS-01234

Programme:
Bite the Bullet
Broadcast / VOD service:
TG4
Date broadcast or accessed:
22.03.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
BAI Code of Programme Standards: Principle 1 – Respect for Community Standards, Principle 2 – Importance of Context
Short description:
The complaint alleges that the movie depicted excessive cruelty and abuse against horses without prior warning or a confirmation following the broadcast that no horses were harmed in the making of the film.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
25.02.2025

CAS-01249

Programme:
The Tommy Tiernan Show
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ One
Date broadcast or accessed:
14.02.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46J(1)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The complainant alleges that a live music performance was crude, offensive and not suitable for broadcast due to the strong language used.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
25.02.2025

CAS-01306

Programme:
Today with Claire Byrne
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ Radio 1
Date broadcast or accessed:
08.03.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46L(1)(b) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The complaint alleges that the use of the word ‘stampede’ by the presenter when referring to the death of 118 Palestinian people, was dehumanising and implied the deaths were caused accidentally rather than as a result of the conflict.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
25.02.2025

CAS-01368

Programme:
The Morning Show with Declan Meehan
Broadcast / VOD service:
East Coast FM
Date broadcast or accessed:
06.03.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46L(1)(b) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The complaint is about an interview with a spokesperson for a local group supporting Palestine, discussing the conflict in Gaza. The complaint alleges that the interviewer showed bias and unfairness, and lacked objectivity and impartiality.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
25.02.2025

CAS-01513

Programme:
The Tonight Show
Broadcast / VOD service:
Virgin Media One
Date broadcast or accessed:
20.11.2023
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46L(1)(b) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The complaint is about a panel discussion concerning the conflict between Israel and Palestine. The complaint alleges the broadcast was presented in a biased and partial manner towards Palestinians and Hamas.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
25.02.2025

CAS-01519

Programme:
Morning Ireland, News item
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ Radio 1
Date broadcast or accessed:
01.02.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46L(1)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The complaint is about an EU Summit to agree a support package for Ukraine following the Hungarian Prime Minister’s earlier veto of the move. The complaint alleges the description of Mr Orban as an ally of Vladimir Putin was inaccurate and displayed partiality.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
25.02.2025

CAS-01562

Programme:
The Oliver Callan Show
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ Radio 1
Date broadcast or accessed:
27.03.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46J(1)(a) & 46J(1)(d) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The complaint is about an illustration described by the presenter that depicted mental health issues in a humorous way prior to an interview examining ADHD and creativity. The complaint alleges that the segment caused harm and incitement of hatred towards the mental health community.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
25.02.2025

CAS-01628

Programme:
The Oliver Callan Show
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ Radio 1
Date broadcast or accessed:
05.04.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46J(1)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The complaint alleges that the interviewer failed to challenge boxing champion Chris Eubank when he mentioned Tony Quinn when discussing the film One Night in Millstreet.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
25.02.2025

CAS-01757

Programme:
4pm News Bulletin
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ One
Date broadcast or accessed:
01.04.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46L(1)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
This news bulletin reported on the attacks on Al-Shifa hospital in Gaza, as well as protests in Jerusalem. The complaint alleges that the broadcaster presented a subjective, inaccurate and partial representation of facts, and omitted important context in the report.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
25.02.2025

CAS-01022

Programme:
Prime Time
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ One
Date broadcast or accessed:
14.12.2023
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Sections 46L(1)(b) & 46J(1)(d) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The complaint is about a programme examining models of care for treating patients with gender identity issues. The complaint alleges the programme lacked fairness and balance.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
12.02.2025

CAS-01624

Programme:
RTÉ Investigates: Ireland's Abortion Services
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ One
Date broadcast or accessed:
15.04.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46L(1)(b) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The programme focused on an examination of the government commissioned report which reviewed the provision of abortion services in Ireland. The complaint alleges that the programme was not impartial or objective and was biased, only sharing pro-abortion views on the matter.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
12.02.2025

CAS-01646

Programme:
9 O'Clock News
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ One
Date broadcast or accessed:
17.04.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46L(1)(a), 46L(1)(b) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The complaint alleges the report on the cancellation of appointments in Irish hospitals was not objective or impartial.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
12.02.2025

CAS-01713

Programme:
RTÉ Investigates: Ireland's Abortion Services
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ One
Date broadcast or accessed:
15.04.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46L(1)(b) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The programme focused on an examination of the government commissioned report which reviewed the provision of abortion services in Ireland. The complaint alleges that the programme was not impartial or objective and was biased, only sharing pro-abortion views on the matter.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
12.02.2025

CAS-01745

Programme:
RTÉ Investigates: Ireland's Abortion Services
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ One
Date broadcast or accessed:
15.04.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46L(1)(b) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The programme focused on an examination of the government commissioned report which reviewed the provision of abortion services in Ireland. The complaint alleges that the programme was not impartial or objective and was biased, only sharing pro-abortion views on the matter.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
12.02.2025

CAS-01756

Programme:
RTÉ Investigates: Ireland's Abortion Services
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ One
Date broadcast or accessed:
15.04.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46K(1) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The complainant alleges that their privacy was unreasonably encroached upon by covert recording in the broadcast
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
12.02.2025

CAS-01760

Programme:
RTÉ Investigates: Ireland's Abortion Services
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ One
Date broadcast or accessed:
15.04.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46L(1)(b) & 46J(1)(d) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The programme focused on an examination of the government commissioned report which reviewed the provision of abortion services in Ireland. The complaint alleges that the programme was not impartial or objective and was biased, only sharing pro-abortion views on the matter.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
12.02.2025

CAS-01813

Programme:
RTÉ Investigates: Ireland's Abortion Services
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ One
Date broadcast or accessed:
15.04.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46L(1)(b) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended. BAI Code of Fairness, Objectivity & Impartiality in News and Current Affairs: Rule 4.1
Short description:
The programme focused on an examination of the government commissioned report which reviewed the provision of abortion services in Ireland. The complaint alleges that the programme was not impartial or objective and was biased, only sharing pro-abortion views on the matter.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
12.02.2025

CAS-01831

Programme:
RTÉ Investigates: Ireland's Abortion Services
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ One
Date broadcast or accessed:
15.04.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46L(1)(b) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The programme focused on an examination of the government commissioned report which reviewed the provision of abortion services in Ireland. The complaint alleges that the programme was not impartial or objective and was biased, only sharing pro-abortion views on the matter.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
12.02.2025

CAS-01846

Programme:
RTÉ Investigates: Ireland's Abortion Services
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ One
Date broadcast or accessed:
15.04.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46L(1)(b) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The programme focused on an examination of the government commissioned report which reviewed the provision of abortion services in Ireland. The complaint alleges that the programme was not impartial or objective and was biased, only sharing pro-abortion views on the matter.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
12.02.2025

CAS-01958

Programme:
RTÉ Investigates: Ireland's Abortion Services
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ One
Date broadcast or accessed:
15.04.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46L(1)(b) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The programme focused on an examination of the government commissioned report which reviewed the provision of abortion services in Ireland. The complaint alleges that impartial or objective and was biased, only sharing pro-abortion views on the matter.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
12.02.2025

CAS-02057

Programme:
Prime Time
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ One
Date broadcast or accessed:
14.12.2023
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Sections 46J(1)(d) & 46L(1)(b) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The complaint is about a programme examining models of care for treating patients with gender identity issues. The complaint alleges the programme lacked fairness and balance.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended
Commission Decision Date:
12.02.2025

CAS-01017

Programme:
Morning Mix
Broadcast / VOD service:
South East Radio
Date broadcast or accessed:
11.12.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Sections 46L(1)(a), 46L(1)(b) & 46K(1) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended. BAI Code of Fairness, Objectivity & Impartiality in News and Current Affairs: Rules 22, 23 & 24. BAI Code of Programme Standards: Principle 7
Short description:
The complaint also concerns broadcasts on the 13th and 14th of December 2024 regarding the same matter. The complaint is about statements readout by the presenter in relation to an off-air incident. The complaint alleges that the presenter was not impartial or balanced, and misquoted statements.
Outcome:
Referred
Commission Decision:
Refer the complaint to an authorised person to be considered for investigation, pursuant to section 48(5) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
21.01.2025

CAS-01092

Programme:
Birds on the Wire
Broadcast / VOD service:
CRKC
Date broadcast or accessed:
06.03.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Sections 46L(1)(b) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The complaint is about a discussion of the Family Bill referenda. The Complaint alleges that the discussion was one-sided and unbalanced.
Outcome:
Referred
Commission Decision:
Refer the complaint to an authorised person to be considered for investigation, pursuant to section 48(5) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
21.01.2025

CAS-01148

Programme:
Country Wide
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ One
Date broadcast or accessed:
17.02.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Sections 46L(1)(b), 46J(1)(a) & 46J(1)(e) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The complaint is about a discussion on the public consultation on the Government’s Threat Response Plan for the Hen Harrier. The complainant alleges that the discussion was misleading, factually incorrect and biased.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
21.01.2025

CAS-01153

Programme:
Upfront with Katie Hannon
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ One
Date broadcast or accessed:
08.01.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46L(1)(b) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Short description:
The complaint is about a debate discussing whether learning the Irish language should be compulsory in Irish schools. The complaint alleges that the composition and conduct of the panel were neither fair to all interests nor presented in an objective and impartial manner.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
21.01.2025

CAS-01155-Z6W5T8

Programme:
The Hard Shoulder
Broadcast / VOD service:
Newstalk 106-108FM
Date broadcast or accessed:
14.02.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
BAI Code of Programme Standards: Principle 1 – Respect for Community Standards, Principle 4 – Protection of Children
Short description:
The complaint is about the use of profane language during the broadcast, which was a discussion on the topic of bad language in a recent movie and the existence of a double standard in perceptions of swearing for men and women.
Outcome:
Referred
Commission Decision:
Refer the complaint to an authorised person to be considered for investigation, pursuant to section 48(5) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
21.01.2025

CAS-01167-P5S9G1

Programme:
Today with Claire Byrne
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ Radio 1
Date broadcast or accessed:
22.01.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Sections 46L(1)(b) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended. BAI Code of Fairness, Objectivity & Impartiality in News and Current Affairs: Rule 1
Short description:
The complaint is about an interview with the former Israeli ambassador. The complaint alleges that statements were made without any challenge and displayed a lack of objectivity.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
21.01.2025

CAS-01298

Programme:
Morning Mix & News Bulletins
Broadcast / VOD service:
South East Radio
Date broadcast or accessed:
11.12.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46L(1)(a) & 46L(1)(b) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended. BAI Code of Fairness, Objectivity & Impartiality in News and Current Affairs: Rules 23 & 24
Short description:
The complaint also concerns broadcasts on the 13th and 14th of December 2024 regarding the same matter. The complaint is about statements read out by the presenter in relation to an off-air incident. The complaint alleges that the presenter was not impartial or balanced, and misquoted statements.
Outcome:
Referred
Commission Decision:
Refer the complaint to an authorised person to be considered for investigation, pursuant to section 48(5) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
21.01.2025

CAS-01535

Programme:
Morning Ireland
Broadcast / VOD service:
RTÉ Radio 1
Date broadcast or accessed:
08.01.2024
Statute and/or regulatory code:
Section 46L(1)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.BAI Code of Fairness, Objectivity & Impartiality in News and Current Affairs: Rule 1
Short description:
The complaint is about a news bulletin which reported on a diplomatic tour of the Middle East by the US Secretary of State and his condemnation of statements from Israel regarding the resettlement of Palestinians outside of Gaza. The complaint alleges that the reporting was inaccurate and may fuel anti-Israel/anti-Jewish sentiment.
Outcome:
Dismissed
Commission Decision:
Dismiss the complaint pursuant to section 48(4)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 2009, as amended.
Commission Decision Date:
21.01.2025

In this section